People keep asking me for the carrot soufflé recipe from the wedding, and sadly the catering company has adopted a Mr. Krabs level of secrecy when it comes to their recipes. I don’t have time to plan an elaborate recipe heist so I figured I would just attempt to recreate it. This was kind of a pain, but I will make sure you do not make the same mistakes I make and hopefully you will have an easier time!
Ingredients:
1.75 lbs of peeled carrots (Buy pre-peeled carrots or have a peeler because ho boy is peeling carrots with a knife is the most tedious thing)
3 eggs
1 stick of butter, softened
3/4ths cup of sugar
2 tablespoons of flour
1.5 teaspoons of baking powder
1.5 teaspoons of vanilla
Powdered sugar for topping
Directions:
Boil carrots until extremely soft and then drain the water. I would recommend cutting them into thin pieces because I did not do this, and it took 17 decades for them to fully soften and I still would have wanted them a little softer.
Preheat your oven to 350.
While your carrots are still warm, add them to a mixer (I think a blender would work okay if you don’t have a mixer) along with your sugar, baking powder, and vanilla.
Whip until smooth. You really want it to be as smooth as possible because I thought mine was smooth enough, but the finished product was still a bit lumpy.
Add your flour and mix it unless completely blended.
Whip your eggs in a separate bowl, and then add them to the mixture.
Add your softened butter and blend that completely as well.
Pour the mixture into a baking pan. You don’t want it any more than half full because it will rise in the pan.
Bake for about an hour or until the top turns light brown. I cooked it for about an hour, but I will probably cook it a little bit longer than that next time because the soufflé from the wedding was a little firmer.
Annoyance Rating (1-10): 8
I think it will be significantly less annoying next time now that I know to buy pre-peeled carrots, cut them into thinner pieces, and soften them more. Hopefully since I told you to do those things it will not be quite this annoying for you. Someone should learn from my mistakes and lord knows it won’t be me.
Erica’s Review:
“I know this recipe was…a process for Jake, but I love that he made it and it was SO SO good. It wasn’t as smooth as the carrot soufflé at our wedding, but the taste was pretty much identical! I love that we can re-live that part of our wedding however often I can convince Jake to make it. I love that it introduced a new recipe to our families that will probably be included in many Thanksgivings to come.”
Recipe I ripped off:
food.com/recipe/picadillys-carrot-souffle-30216
Ooh! I appreciate your efforts and look forward to trying this recipe!
Soft launch wedding announcement lol